Bay Island Real Estate & Homes for Sale

View every home for sale in Bay Island, Sarasota below. Sign up to create an account to receive new property email alerts, price change alerts, track your favorite properties & more!

If you like a homes in Bay Island, Sarasota , you can add it to your favorites, request more information or set up a showing. 

Jump To: Bay Island Listings | Contact Us | Create An Account

Homes For Sale in Bay Island

View All Bay Island Property Listings for Sale July 19, 2024
16
Listed
165
Avg. DOM
$1,221.41
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
$4,650,000
Med. List Price
16 Properties
Page 1 of 2
$6,995,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island
4
Beds
4F11/2
Baths
6,693
Sq.Ft.
1988
Year Built
10
Days on Site
A4616037
MLS
$3,500,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island Shores
3
Beds
3F11/2
Baths
4,399
Sq.Ft.
1951
Year Built
28
Days on Site
U8247711
MLS
Sold
799 Freeling Dr Sarasota,  FL 34242
$9,250,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island Shores
5
Beds
3F21/2
Baths
7,636
Sq.Ft.
1994
Year Built
5/15/24
Sold On
A4596611
MLS
Sold
609 Norsota WAY Sarasota,  FL 34242
$6,400,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island
4
Beds
3
Baths
2,701
Sq.Ft.
1982
Year Built
5/15/24
Sold On
A4602572
MLS
$6,995,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island
4
Beds
4F11/2
Baths
4,711
Sq.Ft.
2024
Year Built
66
Days on Site
A4610537
MLS
Sold
604 Norsota WAY Sarasota,  FL 34242
$3,400,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island
5
Beds
5F11/2
Baths
4,536
Sq.Ft.
1926
Year Built
4/30/24
Sold On
A4603315
MLS
Sold
3650 Flamingo Ave Sarasota,  FL 34242
$4,500,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island
5
Beds
4F11/2
Baths
3,978
Sq.Ft.
2012
Year Built
3/25/24
Sold On
A4599573
MLS
Sold
832 Freeling Dr Sarasota,  FL 34242
$4,800,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island Shores Unit 2
5
Beds
5F11/2
Baths
4,068
Sq.Ft.
1980
Year Built
3/15/24
Sold On
A4594540
MLS
Sold
3472 Anglin Dr Sarasota,  FL 34242
$1,267,800
Neighborhood: Bay Island Park
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,446
Sq.Ft.
1953
Year Built
3/11/24
Sold On
A4596461
MLS
Open 7/21
3458 Anglin Dr Sarasota,  FL 34242
$2,500,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island Park
4
Beds
2F11/2
Baths
2,513
Sq.Ft.
1983
Year Built
131
Days on Site
A4602754
MLS
Sold
3722 Flamingo Ave Sarasota,  FL 34242
$6,650,000
Neighborhood: Bay Island/Siesta Key
5
Beds
5F21/2
Baths
4,985
Sq.Ft.
2023
Year Built
3/1/24
Sold On
A4546740
MLS
$21,000,000
Neighborhood: Siesta Key / Bay Island
4
Beds
4F21/2
Baths
8,138
Sq.Ft.
2016
Year Built
142
Days on Site
A4601040
MLS